This website does not support Internet Explorer. Please, switch to Edge, Chrome, or Firefox browser to view this page.

Learn about IE support

SAP IBP is not a simple upgrade

Adobestock 205571773
Published: Reading time: 5 min
o9 Solutions The Digital Brain Platform
o9 SolutionsThe Digital Brain Platform
Follow on LinkedIn

The discontinuation of support for SAP APO (Advanced Planning and Optimization) is right around the corner. As we’ve discussed in previous blogs, thousands of companies are facing this looming decision. Stay with SAP and upgrade to SAP IBP, or look to a new generation of supply chain management platforms that provide a different user experience, granular insight of operational performance, and elevate competitive differentiation.

Old cell phone technology provides a framework for the future of supply chain planning 

A good analogy is cell phones. In the ‘90s and early 2000’s, cell phones became mainstream and the technology at the time was state of the art. Customers purchased flip phones with no apps, low quality black and white screens, and text functionality that required strength training for your hands due to the number of keystrokes required to type a message. We’re looking at you Motorola StarTAC. 

Today, cell phones can do myriad things with power, speed, connectivity and simplicity. They are voice-enabled to make things easier, they have apps that are constantly being rolled out that not only handle a specific task, but can integrate with other apps to provide deeper insights into a “bigger picture,” and not only run on the network, but also on the internet. In short, they are flexible, scalable, and more holistically connected.

Now think about what it would look like to migrate from that 1996 StarTac to an iPhone 13 today. This is where the IBP and the o9 Digital Brain story comes in. 

Three Things to Keep In Mind

When evaluating solutions to replace the supply chain planning equivalent of the 1996 StarTac the big takeaway is don’t be lulled into a false sense of security thinking that this will be a fast, easy, seamless transition. IBP is not a simple one-to-one swap, even if it’s being marketed that way. The biggest issue to consider is that not all APO functionality is part of IBP, such as PP/DS (production planning/detailed scheduling). Decision makers should realize when evaluating options that SAP is forcing customers who have SAP APO PPDS to wait for an S/4 implementation to get that functionality back into their stack. Furthermore, as mentioned earlier, moving to S/4 to regain this functionality will be tricky, particularly if there is heavy customization of the legacy platform, and will require further consideration of the upgrade team. But at a fundamental level, there are three main reasons to understand why it’s more complicated than you may have been told. 

  • 1.

    Integration challenges
    As mentioned earlier, upgrading to SAP IBP is not a simple 1:1 swap from APO. IBP is a stand alone solution separate from SAP ERP S/4 HANA and requires integration to other SAP applications, as well as other best of breed applications. So even if you’ve been using APO for years, there are going to be growing pains and struggles to migrate onto IBP. For example, an IBP scenario doesn’t automatically feed into and update financial planning scenarios, creating an information divide between the two systems. This gap prevents efficient decision making because two plans are being created with two different sets of assumptions at varying planning levels. This will cost your organization time, money and accuracy throughout your supply chain planning efforts.
  • 2.

    It’s not cloud native
    We’d like to separate the hype of being cloud native from the reality of being cloud native. Ultimately, being cloud native means greater adaptability in your IT environment. That’s because the architecture is able to scale without restrictions, has greater cost benefits, and allows for easier ingestion of internal and external data sources. This ability to ingest external data is critical in demand planning, as these external data sets are often a better predictor of demand than historical data.
  • 3.

    It’s not flexible
    Like being cloud-native, flexibility is a buzz word that isn’t well defined yet, which has significant implications. Flexibility in a supply chain planning platform is referring to the ability of the solution to bend and mold to the workflows and existing process, as opposed to the workflows getting manhandled to fit software capabilities. Even though it is less rigid than APO, SAP IBP can’t be customized easily to fit customer needs, solve their problems, and grow with the organization. It can be customized with a great deal of cost and effort, which is a trade off. More importantly, the upgrade revolves around the data model that IBP uses as a jumping off point. The two most common states of which are that it’s either too detailed or not detailed enough, and you cannot change it for the main dimensions, and add external data, which holds a significant amount of market intelligence, into the original model. This prevents companies from unlocking insights that they aren’t aware of given the current limitations of IBP.

We all look back on the technology from yesteryear with rose-colored glasses. There is nostalgia for the earlier products, whether cell phones or supply chain planning software. When they first came out, they did the best job they could at the time, but our needs and businesses evolve and with that comes a need for new solutions. If your organization is ready for the next generation of supply chain planning that integrates well, is cloud-native and is designed with flexibility at its core, then download our latest white paper, Beyond APO Selecting a new planning platform.

Mobile phone

Get free industry updates

Each quarter, we'll send you o9 Magazine with the latest supply chain industry news, trends, and o9 knowledge. Don’t miss out!

About the author

o9 Solutions The Digital Brain Platform

o9 Solutions

The Digital Brain Platform

o9 Solutions is a leading AI-powered platform for integrated business planning and decision-making for the enterprise. Whether it is driving demand, aligning demand and supply, or optimizing commercial initiatives, any planning process can be made faster and smarter with o9’s AI-powered digital solutions. o9 brings together technology innovations—such as graph-based enterprise modeling, big data analytics, advanced algorithms for scenario planning, collaborative portals, easy-to-use interfaces and cloud-based delivery—into one platform.


View our related articles, white papers, use cases & videos

article3 min

The Head-Turning Effect of Next-Gen Retail Assortment Planning

by o9 Solutions
Copy of o9designlab assortment planning blog1 header v1
video7 min

The o9 Cybersecurity Advantage: Unlocking the Secrets of Top-Ranked Security

Auto draft thumbnail
article4 min

The Secret to Staying Ahead of Demand Planning in Apparel, Footwear & Luxury

by Todd Vanselus
O9 tackling demand planning challenges blog header 2048×936 v1

aim10x OnTour Taipei

Taiwan (1)
article9 min

What is Inventory Allocation?

by o9 Solutions
Seo blog inventory allocation blog header v1
article14 min

The Takeaways from aim10x Munich 2024

by Alberto Fabregat
Hero image blog page
Magazine10 min

aim10x Magazine - 2024 E1

Aim10x magazine 2024e1 mockup

Mastering the Art and Science of Assortment Planning

o9 whitepaper assortment planning mockup
article15 min

The Takeaways from Growth Leaders Summit London 2024

by James Griffiths
Hero image blog page
article16 min

The Takeaways from aim10x Chicago 2024

by o9 Solutions
Hero image blog page
news2 min

o9 Digitally Transforms Iveco Group’s Integrated Business Planning Processes 

by o9 Solutions
Iveco newsroom banner v1 (1)
article4 min

Each Step Counts: What o9 Walks Means to Our Community

by Igor Rikalo
O9 walks blog page