Building a Future-Ready Supply Chain: Strategies for Effective Supplier Collaboration

Modern-day suppliers frequently receive numerous requests from buyers to enhance resiliency, sustainability, and efficiency—and these demands are complex and multifaceted. Suppliers not only face challenges due to the number of buyers seeking various types of data, but they also deal with the same buyer approaching them through different channels of communication. This often requires significant manual data management in response to sustainability requests, which is further complicated by a lack of understanding of the benefits and mixed maturity levels across the supplier base.

This complexity makes it challenging to gather the necessary data for compliance with regulations such as CSRD, CBAM, EUDR, and others. Additionally, a key challenge is identifying the incentive levers that can motivate suppliers to engage in collaboration and adopt sustainability practices. This blog will explore strategies to address these issues.

The Challenge of Data Homogeneity and Supplier Maturity

Firstly, let's unpack the challenge buyers face due to varying maturity levels within their supplier base, which leads to data homogeneity issues. Companies often work with suppliers of all sizes, each managing its own network, resulting in a multitier supply chain. The majority of this network comprises small and medium enterprises (SMEs) that typically lack an internal sustainability team. Many of these organizations have competitive priorities that prevent them from engaging in or even considering sustainability practices, let alone having the financial means to invest in such initiatives (Reynolds, 2024).

This lack of internal expertise leads to a vast diversity in the types of sustainability data companies receive from their supply base. Some suppliers may not even know how to spell "GHG protocol," let alone calculate a carbon footprint per product, given the various methodologies and forms available. Additionally, buyers and suppliers may use different terminologies and manage data differently, needing significant data cleansing, standardization, and harmonization activities to enable effective collaboration.

The Burden of Data Collaboration Requests

On top of this, suppliers often receive data collaboration requests from various customer departments on multiple topics. For instance, they may be asked to share forecasts, inventory availability, specific order information, environmental certifications, OSHA compliance, product-specific certifications, sustainability targets, and information about their own supplier networks. These requests often come in different formats and through various technologies, making the process tedious and time-consuming.

Strategies for Enhanced Collaboration and Sustainability Engagement

So, what should companies do to solve these problems? What levers should they focus on to engage their suppliers and motivate them towards more sustainable practices? How can they facilitate collaboration while addressing the initial challenges mentioned?

Companies must understand how to facilitate effective data-related collaboration within their supply base. This can be achieved through a well-structured data governance and operating model. According to McKinsey, good practices include:

• Understanding the relative value of internal and trade partner data
• Managing data throughout its lifecycle with audit trails, approval steps, and quality assurance
• Deriving value from data through analytics and use case identification
• Sharing data in real-time in a secure and controlled manner using common standards (The Digital, Vertical, Resilient Supply Chain | McKinsey, n.d.)

By implementing these practices, companies can significantly improve the efficiency and effectiveness of their supplier collaborations, leading to enhanced resiliency, sustainability, and overall supply chain performance.

Identifying Supplier Motivators

Understanding what motivates suppliers to collaborate and engage in sustainability practices is crucial. It's also important to identify ways to help suppliers acquire the knowledge needed to start this engagement process. Research indicates that the primary motivator for companies of all sizes to engage in these practices is the potential for competitive advantage and market differentiation. Essentially, sustainability is not just about ethical practices; it's also about cost savings.

However, SMEs often struggle to justify the upfront investments required for sustainable practices. These include implementing necessary technologies and acquiring the information needed to collaborate with stakeholders, all while operating on thin margins (Understanding the Shapers of Sustainability in Small Businesses, n.d.). For some suppliers, local regulations are a significant motivator, as non-compliance can jeopardize their business. This is less of a concern for others.

This difference in motivation is notable between large companies and SMEs. For SMEs, motivation is more likely driven by community ties, local regulatory compliance, and market demands rather than global pressures (Klewitz & Hansen, 2014). Collaboration with larger companies can thus provide SMEs with incentives to become more sustainable. These incentives can highlight market opportunities and potentially shift the focus of SME leadership towards more strategic data readiness for collaboration and sustainability efforts.

The Role of Large Companies

For large companies, incentivizing deeper and more strategic collaboration with their suppliers is not only a matter of compliance but also a competitive advantage. Large companies often face inertia, making changes harder to implement. In contrast, SMEs are sometimes more agile. By encouraging SMEs to adopt sustainability practices and make necessary investments, large companies can enhance their competitiveness and improve relationships and efficiency with their suppliers.

Moreover, creating a streamlined and comprehensive vehicle for supplier collaboration will increase resilience for both parties. This contributes to the development of a robust and dynamic supply chain capable of adapting to changing market conditions, regulatory requirements, and societal expectations (Aal, 2024).

Leveraging Technology for Effective Collaboration

In terms of technology, a platform approach is highly effective for improving collaboration with suppliers. Supplier fatigue is a real issue, especially when requirements and requests come from the same customer through different systems. The value captured by creating a digital twin of the partner network—comprising components, machines, factories, and supply chain relationships—and incorporating the information required for collaboration across various aspects, including sustainability requirements, in a single system is significant.

By leveraging information for multiple frameworks and requiring suppliers to fill in one data point instead of multiple across various systems, companies can achieve a significant productivity leap in their relationships. Furthermore, if the same platform can model production systems, include risk information, and integrate these elements to enable smart decision-making, the possibilities for value capture increase exponentially (The Digital, Vertical, Resilient Supply Chain | McKinsey, n.d.)

This approach not only reduces supplier fatigue but also enhances overall efficiency and effectiveness, contributing to a more resilient and adaptive supply chain.

In Conclusion

Addressing the challenges of data homogeneity, supplier maturity, and data collaboration requests requires a strategic approach that combines effective data governance, understanding supplier motivators, leveraging technology, and fostering collaboration.

By implementing robust data governance models, companies can ensure the quality and consistency of data shared across the supply chain. Recognizing and addressing the specific motivators for suppliers can drive greater engagement and adoption of sustainable practices. Leveraging advanced technology, such as digital twins and integrated platforms, can streamline data sharing and collaboration, reducing supplier fatigue and enhancing productivity.

Fostering a culture of collaboration and open communication with suppliers can further enhance the resiliency, sustainability, and efficiency of the supply chain. This strategic approach enables companies to build a more robust and dynamic network capable of adapting to evolving market conditions and regulatory demands, ultimately leading to competitive advantage and long-term success.

References

Aal, S. I. A. (2024). A Multi-Criteria Decision Making Model for Sustainable and Resilient Supplier Selection and Management. Neutrosophic Systems with Applications, 15, 33–45. (source)

Dang, T.-T., Nguyen, N.-A.-T., Nguyen, V.-T.-T., & Dang, L.-T.-H. (2022). A Two-Stage Multi-Criteria Supplier Selection Model for Sustainable Automotive Supply Chain under Uncertainty. Axioms, 11(5), Article 5. (source)

(PDF) Understanding the shapers of sustainability in small businesses. (n.d.). Retrieved January 10, 2025. (source)

Reynolds, S. (2024). Uncovering the Motivations and Barriers for Suppliers in Adopting Sustainable Practices.

Research Square. The digital, vertical, resilient supply chain | McKinsey. (n.d.). Retrieved January 10, 2025, from (source)

o9 Achieves Catena-X Demand and Capacity Management Certification, the Automotive Industry’s First Open and Collaborative Data Ecosystem

The Certification Marks o9’s Position as a Frontrunner and Trusted Provider of Interoperable and Secure Solutions for the Automotive Value Chain

Read the full press release