The 4 Retail Strategies for Winning Customer Loyalty in 2025

Discounts may still drive short-term volume, but they no longer guarantee loyalty. Today’s customers are choosing where they shop (and what they stick with) based on a wider definition of value: not just what they pay, but what they get in return. Retailers who are winning in this environment aren’t just lowering prices. They’re also raising the standard across personalization, sustainability, convenience, and pricing transparency.

Here’s how forward-looking retailers are building loyalty that lasts, and without racing to the bottom.

1. Personalization is the new loyalty program

What once felt like a “nice to have” is now an expectation. Shoppers want experiences that feel tailored to their needs, whether they’re browsing online, walking into a flagship store, or checking out through an app.

AI has shifted personalization from manual guesswork to dynamic, real-time relevance. Leading retailers are using machine learning to analyze browsing behavior, purchase patterns, and regional preferences to surface the right products at the right moments. Store clustering ensures local assortments reflect actual demand, while targeted promotions replace blunt, blanket markdowns with something more refined and far more effective.

For retailers, personalization also benefits from a tighter link between CRM and demand planning. Integrating sales pipeline data into planning processes allows teams to align inventory, highlight shifting buyer intent, and prioritize high-impact opportunities, improving both service levels and sell-through.

In addition to delighting the customer, personalization also improves margin, reduces waste, and gives retailers a more precise lens through which to plan and execute.

2. Sustainable sourcing fuels trust and profits

Retailers that lead on sustainable sourcing aren’t just swapping materials. They’re reshaping sourcing strategies entirely. Ethical supplier partnerships reduce exposure to labor and regulatory risk. Local and nearshoring efforts cut transport costs and emissions, while improving agility. And when recycled or renewable materials are brought into the mix, customers respond with greater trust and a higher willingness to pay.

This isn’t just good for brand equity. It’s good for business. At o9, we’ve seen retailers realize measurable gains from sustainable sourcing, including $165 million in COGS reduction, 47% shorter lead times, and up to $9 million in reduced excess and obsolete inventory. Margin improvements of 3% or more are not uncommon when sustainability is embedded as part of the broader sourcing strategy.

When planned for holistically, sustainability becomes a driver of both efficiency and differentiation. With improved traceability powered by AI and blockchain, retailers can ensure ethical sourcing and prevent supply chain fraud while also enabling smarter inventory allocation tied to sustainability goals.

3. Convenience is table stakes, but execution still differentiates

It’s no secret that convenience drives conversion. What’s changed is the baseline for what convenience looks like.

Today’s consumers expect the ability to browse, buy, return, and reorder seamlessly across every touchpoint. That means inventory visibility across stores and warehouses. It means flexible checkout options and fulfillment that meets the moment, whether it’s same-day delivery or in-store pickup. And it means treating mobile, desktop, and in-store channels not as separate funnels, but as extensions of a single, coherent experience.

For many retailers, the real challenge isn’t knowing what to deliver—it’s building the systems that make it sustainable. The ones who get it right turn ease into engagement, and engagement into loyalty.

4. Clarity beats complexity at the checkout

Pricing is still powerful, but not when it’s confusing. The retail industry has trained customers to wait for deals. Constant markdowns, limited-time offers, and stacked discounts have become the norm, eroding both trust and profitability. It’s no surprise that off-price retailers, who embrace transparent pricing models and consistent value, continue to outperform their promotional-heavy peers.

Off-price offers a valuable lesson: keep pricing simple, and customers keep coming back. Their “everyday low pricing” models eliminate the guesswork. Instead of hunting for discounts, shoppers trust that they’re getting a fair deal every time. In uncertain economic environments or during tariff fluctuations, this model becomes even more attractive, not only to shoppers but also to vendors looking to offload inventory quickly.

Simplifying pricing doesn’t mean abandoning competitiveness. It means creating a pricing structure that customers can understand and believe in. Fewer, more meaningful promotions. Everyday low pricing where it makes sense. Transparent pricing across channels. When customers trust that they’re getting fair value, they stop waiting for the next sale and start buying with confidence.

While smart pricing is about clarity, it’s also about allocation. Some retailers are prioritizing strategic stores with consistent value offers, ensuring the right products are available to the right segments at the right time.

The impact goes beyond perception. Clear pricing strategies reduce margin leakage, improve planning accuracy, and build a foundation of trust that’s hard to discount away.

The future of retail value is broader than discounts

Customers don’t just want the lowest price; they understandably want the best experience for their money. Retailers that focus on delivering consistent, differentiated value across personalization, sustainability, convenience, and clarity are building loyalty that endures beyond the next sale.

As market conditions tighten and promotional fatigue grows, these capabilities aren’t just differentiators. They’re necessities. For retailers looking to improve margins, simplify planning, and build customer relationships that last, this is the long story short: stop competing on price alone and start tuning in to what matters most to your customers.

Take a tour

See how the o9 Digital Brain unifies planning, forecasting, and execution through AI-driven intelligence.

Platform tour